
On Friday, April 24, 2026, a three-judge panel at the Board of Immigration Appeals issued a DACA ruling that changed the legal landscape for about half a million people living in the United States. The ruling is straightforward. DACA status is no longer automatic protection from deportation.
That is not a small change. Since 2012, the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program has functioned as a shield. It was an Obama-era executive action that let immigration judges halt removal proceedings because a person had DACA status. Friday’s BIA decision removed that automatic shield. It did not immediately deport anyone. Even so, it changed the legal foundation on which hundreds of thousands of people have built their lives.
The Case Behind the DACA Ruling: Catalina Santiago
The decision came out of Matter of Santiago-Santiago, 29 I&N Dec. 589, a published, precedent-setting opinion. The respondent is Catalina Santiago-Santiago, known publicly as Catalina Xóchitl Santiago, a DACA recipient. NPR reports that she was detained by Customs and Border Protection officers in August 2025 while boarding a domestic flight at the El Paso airport. She was placed in immigration detention and later released by a federal judge in October. She has been fighting removal in immigration court since.
The Board’s opinion says she was placed in removal proceedings on Aug. 5, 2025, and charged as present without admission or parole. She moved to terminate the case because she has DACA. She also alleged she was prima facie eligible to adjust status based on marriage to a U.S. citizen. DHS opposed. It argued that deferred action does not confer a right to remain and does not stop removal proceedings. On Sept. 8, 2025, Immigration Judge Michael Pleters terminated the case based on her DACA status. DHS appealed.
The three-judge panel sided with DHS. It held that the immigration judge erred by terminating the proceedings based solely on DACA status, without considering DHS’s reasons for opposing termination. The regulations allow discretionary termination when a person has deferred action, the Board said. However, that decision is an exercise of discretion. It requires a look at why termination is sought and why the government objects. In other words, DACA is a factor. It is not a trump card. The case was therefore sent back for a new decision.
Why the Board Reassigned the Case
The Board also directed that the case go to a different immigration judge, “in an abundance of caution,” to avoid the appearance of partiality. DHS had argued that the original judge should be recused because his spouse, a member of Congress, had advocated for Santiago. NPR identified that spouse as Democratic Rep. Veronica Escobar of Texas. The Board said it did not need to decide the recusal motion on the merits once it was reassigning the case.
That is a narrower point than a claim that the first judge’s legal reasoning was “fundamentally flawed” in some extra sense. The legal error the Board named was the failure to weigh the government’s opposition.
What the DACA Ruling Actually Says
The BIA’s precedent now tells immigration judges nationwide that they must weigh all relevant factors in a termination request. They may not simply defer to DACA status as dispositive. As a result, DHS lawyers can argue, in any DACA recipient’s case already in removal proceedings, that the specific circumstances warrant going forward.
The program itself still exists. Renewals are still available. But active DACA status no longer automatically closes the door on a deportation case.
As EdSource reported, the decision potentially weakens protections for roughly 506,000 DACA recipients, including more than 141,000 in California. NPR similarly put the population at around half a million. It also noted that the administration has tried to strip benefits from about 505,000 recipients even though no regulation has ended the program. The youngest recipients are around 24, EdSource said, and the oldest about 45, because the government stopped accepting new applications in late 2017. In California alone, an estimated 6,784 educators across K-12 and higher education have DACA status, according to the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education, cited by EdSource.
Renewals Are Already Slowing
Renewals have also slowed. EdSource said processing times now stretch over five months in many cases. In addition, there is no grace period if a work permit expires while a renewal is pending. Recipients can lose work authorization, and the legal status that comes with it, before the paperwork is finished. That is a separate problem from Friday’s ruling. Still, it makes the ruling land harder.
The Conservative Case — Both Sides of It
The conservative argument for this ruling is straightforward, and it is legitimate. DACA was created by executive action, without a statute from Congress that settled these cases. A temporary policy of deferred action was never supposed to become a permanent, automatic bar to removal proceedings. The BIA is right that immigration judges should not treat an executive program as if it were a law Congress passed. Discretion means considering the whole file, including the government’s interest in finishing a case.
The humanitarian argument is also real. Conservatives should not pretend otherwise. These are people who were brought to the United States as children. They did not make the decision to cross the border. Many have lived here since they were small children, and many have built careers, families and communities in reliance on a policy the government itself created. A three-judge administrative panel can change how courts treat that policy. It cannot honestly call that a substitute for legislation.
Congress Still Has to Write a Law
The principled conservative answer is the one I’ve applied in other immigration fights, including later coverage of deaths in ICE custody and of border and ICE funding: Congress should do its job. For years, both parties have used DACA recipients as a talking point and a bargaining chip rather than passing a statute that would resolve their status, one way or another, under the law. That failure belongs to both parties. Enforcement of immigration law is necessary. So is a legislature willing to write clear rules instead of leaving half a million people in a policy that can be widened or narrowed by the next memo or the next Board decision.
Five hundred thousand people are not abstractions. They are the result of a country that spent decades failing to control the border, then created a temporary executive program, then never replaced it with a statute. The DACA ruling does not resolve that mess. Instead, it intensifies it. The Board was careful to say it expressed no opinion on the ultimate outcome of Santiago’s own case. A footnote in the opinion notes that she cannot be removed while her DACA protection remains in effect. That should be stated plainly. This decision is about how judges handle cases, not a mass deportation order issued on a Friday afternoon.
Congress, which created this problem through inaction, now has another opportunity to do its job. It probably will not. But it should. If Republicans want a durable enforcement policy, they should pass one. If Democrats want a durable protection, they should pass one too. Until that happens, immigration judges will follow the new precedent, DHS will bring more of these cases, and families will live with a shield that is no longer automatic.
Correction (November 2026)
The Board of Immigration Appeals issued Matter of Santiago-Santiago on Friday, April 24, 2026, not April 25. The ruling applies to how immigration judges treat DACA recipients already in removal proceedings. It does not, by itself, end anyone’s DACA status or order the immediate deportation of half a million people. An earlier version of this post also used an unverified personal anecdote in the opening and overstated the reason the case was reassigned to a different judge.
Sources
- Board of Immigration Appeals: Matter of Santiago-Santiago, 29 I&N Dec. 589 (BIA 2026), decided April 24, 2026
- NPR: Justice Department makes it easier to deport those with DACA status; Santiago detention and release; 505,000 figure
- EdSource: roughly 506,000 recipients; California and educator figures; renewal delays and no grace period










