Twenty-nine people died in Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody between October 1, 2025, and mid-April 2026, according to government data reported by NPR. That already passed the previous full-year record of 28, set in fiscal 2004, with five and a half months of the fiscal year still to go.
Those are not just numbers. They are people the federal government took into its custody and did not bring out alive. Supporting strong immigration enforcement, as I do, does not mean looking away from that. It means asking what the data shows, what the government says, and what Congress should require.
What the Data Shows on Deaths in ICE Custody
Start with the headline figures. Each one comes from government data or official reports, as reported by NPR and NBC News.
- Fiscal 2026 to date: 29 deaths as of April 17, a new record (NPR).
- Calendar 2026 to date: 17 deaths by mid-April, roughly one a week (NBC News).
- Calendar 2025: 33 deaths, the highest in more than two decades, up from 11 in 2024 (NBC News).
- Detention population: about 60,000 people in April, with detentions up more than 70 percent compared with the first year of the Biden administration (NPR, NBC News).
NBC News also noted that the detention population, while still far above where it stood before President Trump returned to office, has declined in recent months. That matters when we look at the pace of deaths in ICE custody later in the year.
Where and How People Died
Adelanto in California and Camp East Montana in El Paso each reported three deaths, the most of any facility. ICE’s initial reports on those six deaths list causes including suicide, alcohol withdrawal, liver failure and kidney failure.
One death at Camp East Montana stands out. DHS first said Geraldo Lunas Campos died after “medical distress” and had become “disruptive while in line for medication.” The El Paso County Medical Examiner’s Office later ruled his death a homicide, and the FBI is investigating, NPR reports. DHS says he had multiple criminal convictions. His three children have said in a court petition that they plan to file a wrongful death lawsuit.
Criminal records do not change the core point about deaths in ICE custody. When a medical examiner rules a death in federal custody a homicide, the public deserves a full accounting, whoever the detainee was.
The most recent case at the time was Aled Damien Carbonell-Betancourt, a 27-year-old Cuban man found unresponsive in his cell at a federal detention center in Miami on April 12. ICE listed a presumed suicide, with the official cause still under investigation. According to ICE, he entered the country in 2024 without valid documents, was released on parole, and was arrested in 2025 for resisting an officer with violence before being moved into ICE custody.
Rate Versus Count: The Government’s Answer
The administration’s argument is about scale. At a House hearing on April 16, acting ICE Director Todd Lyons said deaths were high “because we do have the highest amount in detention that ICE has ever had since its inception in 2003.” DHS told NPR it denies any spike and said death rates were “0.009% of the detained population.” Lyons said the agency spent “almost half a billion dollars last fiscal year” on detainee care, and that detainees get a full physical within 14 days and see a medical professional within 24 hours of admission.
“No death is what we want. We don’t want anyone to die in custody,” Lyons said. His written testimony adds that ICE’s Office of Detention Oversight conducted more than 100 compliance inspections and 20 detainee death reviews.
That point deserves a fair hearing. More people in detention will, all else equal, mean more deaths. But “all else equal” is the question. A detention population roughly 70 percent larger does not by itself explain deaths tripling from 11 in 2024 to 33 in 2025. And a statement that “for many illegal aliens this is the best healthcare they have received their entire lives,” which DHS gave NPR, is not an answer to a homicide ruling.
Lyons announced his resignation hours after he testified, effective May 31, NPR reports. It was not immediately clear why he was leaving. His exit follows other turnover at the top of DHS, including Markwayne Mullin replacing Kristi Noem as secretary, part of a wider run of departures we wrote about in Trump’s third Cabinet loss in four months.
The Reporting Gap
Congress requires ICE to make reports on in-custody deaths public within 90 days, according to ICE’s own detainee death page. Faster interim notices matter too. On April 13, Georgia Sens. Jon Ossoff and Raphael Warnock wrote that of 49 deaths since January 2025, “ICE has issued an interim death notice within 48 hours in only 15 cases.”
NBC News reported that ICE also missed the 90-day deadline for four January deaths, those of Victor Manuel Diaz, Heber Sanchez Dominguez, Parady La and Luis Nunez Caceres, and posted those reports only after the delay was reported. When Lyons was asked how many people still work in the Office of Detention Oversight, the office that inspects facilities, he could not give a number.
Lyons said ICE treated death reporting as essential work even during the current funding lapse. “We are reporting. We are working on that timeline,” he told the committee. Even so, a written promise is not the same as reports that arrive on time.
Why Accountability for ICE Custody Is a Conservative Value
Conservatives believe in limited government precisely because government power can be misused. Detention is the government at its most powerful: it decides where you sleep, what you eat, and whether you see a doctor. That is exactly where rules and transparency matter most.
There is also a money question. Lyons’ own testimony credits last summer’s reconciliation law with “a historic $75 billion for ICE,” funding that has paid for about 11,000 new officers and agents and a new detention model. Taxpayers are entitled to know whether that money is buying safe, lawful detention or just more beds. We broke down what the $70 billion Secure America Act would fund on top of that. Missing reporting deadlines is not a paperwork problem. It is an agency ignoring the people who fund it.
Enforcement is moving fast on other fronts too, as our look at why DACA is no longer a shield showed. The faster the system moves, the more it needs guardrails people can see.
What Congress Should Require
- Enforce the 48-hour and 90-day reporting deadlines, with a public monthly count of deaths and causes.
- Publish staffing and inspection numbers for the Office of Detention Oversight, and fund it in proportion to the detention population.
- Require independent review of every death ruled a homicide or suicide, and of any facility with repeat deaths.
None of this weakens enforcement. People who are in the country illegally can be detained and removed under the law. The government that detains them is also bound by the law. Holding both of those at once is not soft. It is what the rule of law means.
Update (November 2026)
Added November 2026. Fiscal 2026 ended September 30. ICE’s public detainee death page lists 36 deaths for the year, the last on August 23, well above the 2004 record of 28 and the most of any year on the page, which goes back to fiscal 2018. The pace slowed after spring: 29 deaths came through April 12 and seven more after. Under the 90-day rule, any later deaths may not yet be listed.
Sources
- NPR: Deaths of migrants in ICE custody hit record high under Trump
- NBC News: ICE releases delayed detainee death reports as 2026 total rises to 17
- House Appropriations Homeland Security Subcommittee: Lyons written testimony, April 16, 2026
- NPR: ICE acting director Lyons will resign at end of May
- ICE: Detainee Death Reporting










