Why are gas prices so high? The honest answer is that a gallon of gasoline is four bills stapled together: crude oil, refining, getting the fuel to your corner station, and taxes. When any one of them jumps, you pay for it at the pump. This year, two of them jumped at once.
Start with where we are. The Energy Information Administration says regular gasoline averaged $3.81 a gallon nationally on November 16. That’s down 19 cents in a week, which is real relief. However, it’s still 74 cents higher than the same week last year, when the average was $3.06.
The swing inside 2026 has been even wilder. Gas averaged $2.81 in January and $4.48 in May, a jump of $1.67 in four months. I’ve covered the news behind that, from the $117 oil spike tied to Iran to diesel staying stuck above $6. This piece is different. Instead, I want to walk through what makes up the price of a gallon.
Why Are Gas Prices So High? Start With What’s in a Gallon
The EIA breaks every gallon of regular into four parts. Its most recent breakdown covers August 2026, when the average gallon cost $4.06. Crude oil made up 50.3% of that price. Refining costs and profits took 24.4%. Taxes were 12.9%, and distribution and marketing came to 12.5%.

Now compare that with August 2025, when gas averaged $3.13. Using the EIA’s own pump components history, I converted those shares into dollars. Crude went from about $1.58 a gallon to about $2.04. Refining went from about 55 cents to about 99 cents. Taxes and distribution barely moved.
In other words, nearly all of the 93-cent increase came from two places. Crude added roughly 46 cents, and refining added roughly 44 cents. That split matters, because each one has a different cause and a different fix.
Crude Oil Is Half the Price, and It’s Set Globally
Oil trades on a world market. As a result, a driver in Iowa pays a price set by traders from Houston to Singapore. When supply gets scarce anywhere, it shows up here.
That’s what happened this year. In its November Short-Term Energy Outlook, the EIA pointed to falling global inventories, attacks on oil tankers in the Persian Gulf, tight shipping capacity and higher transportation costs. It expects Brent crude, the global benchmark, to stay near $100 a barrel for the rest of the year. Brent averaged $69 in 2025.
The tension around Iran and the Strait of Hormuz is the main reason. I won’t rehash the military side here. Still, the economics are simple. When a chokepoint for Middle East oil is under threat, traders price in the risk before a barrel goes missing.
Meanwhile, American production is the cushion. The EIA expects U.S. crude output to average 13.9 million barrels a day this year and reach a record 14.3 million in 2027. Without that output, this shock would have hit harder.
Taxes: The Same Cents, Whether Gas Is $3 or $5
Taxes are the most stable piece of the price. The federal gasoline tax is 18.4 cents a gallon. That figure is 18.3 cents of excise tax plus a one-tenth-cent fee for leaking underground storage tanks.
States add their own layer, and the gap between them is huge. According to the EIA’s federal and state motor fuel tax table, state taxes and fees averaged 33.8 cents a gallon as of July 1, 2026. California charged the most at 73.6 cents. Illinois was close behind at 71.7 cents. Alaska charged the least at about 9 cents, and Texas charged 20 cents.
Because these taxes are cents per gallon, their share shrinks when prices rise. In August 2025, taxes were 16.4% of the price. A year later, they were 12.9%, even though the dollar amount was almost identical.
Also, those state numbers leave out local option taxes and some sales taxes. So the real gap between states can run even wider.
Refining Capacity Is the Bottleneck Nobody Builds
Crude oil is useless in a gas tank. It has to be refined, and America’s refining base keeps getting smaller. As of January 1, 2026, the EIA counted 130 operable refineries with about 18.2 million barrels a day of distillation capacity, according to its Refinery Capacity Report.
Two more plants stopped refining crude during 2025. One was in Houston, with about 264,000 barrels a day of capacity, and the other was Phillips 66 in Los Angeles, with about 139,000. That’s roughly 400,000 barrels a day gone in a single year.
The EIA also notes that the newest U.S. refinery with significant downstream units came online in 1977. Existing plants have expanded since then, which has kept supply growing. Still, the country hasn’t built a major new refinery in nearly 50 years.
That’s why refining margins exploded this year. The EIA expects global fuel markets to stay supply-constrained through the end of 2027, with wider margins for refiners. When there’s barely enough capacity to go around, every outage or closure becomes a price spike.

Summer Blends, Boutique Fuels and the California Problem
Gasoline isn’t one product. Instead, it changes by season and by region, and each change adds cost.
In summer, environmental rules require gasoline that evaporates less in the heat. According to the EIA, refiners have to swap in more expensive components to meet that standard. Demand also rises when families drive more. From 2004 through 2023, the EIA found that August gas averaged about 40 cents a gallon more than January.
Then there are special blends. About one-third of the gasoline sold in the United States is reformulated to cut smog in certain areas. On top of the federal program, some states and cities require their own versions. Each of these “boutique” fuels narrows the number of refineries that can supply a given market.
California is the extreme case. The EIA says relatively few refineries make California’s unique blend, and its program is stricter than the federal one. As a result, the state’s refineries have to run near full capacity. When one or two have problems, replacement fuel from the Gulf Coast or overseas can take a long time to arrive.
The numbers show the cost. For example, on November 16, California averaged $5.39 a gallon. Texas averaged $3.22. The Midwest was at $3.60. In my view, much of that $2.17 gap between California and Texas is policy: higher taxes, a stricter blend and a shrinking refinery base.
What to Watch Over the Next Year
The EIA forecasts that regular gasoline will average $3.89 for all of 2026 and $3.73 in 2027. That’s lower than this year. However, it’s higher than the $3.56 the agency expected for 2027 just a month earlier.
Three things will decide whether that forecast holds. First, watch the Persian Gulf, because tanker traffic sets the risk premium on crude. Second, watch refinery outages, especially on the West Coast. Third, watch inventories. U.S. commercial crude stocks fell to 410 million barrels at the end of October, the lowest end-of-October level since 2014.
Low inventories mean less margin for error. So even with prices falling now, one bad week overseas could push them back up.
What Each Side Proposes
The left’s answer usually starts with blaming the oil companies. That means windfall-profit taxes, price-gouging penalties and more state oversight. I’ve written about why a windfall tax won’t lower your gas bill. Taxing a product doesn’t create more of it.
The other common idea is a temporary gas tax holiday. It sounds generous, and the federal piece would save drivers up to 18.4 cents a gallon. But it doesn’t add a barrel of crude or a gallon of refining capacity. Furthermore, that tax exists to pay for highways, so the gap has to be covered somewhere.
The right’s answer focuses on supply. That means more domestic drilling, faster permits for pipelines and refineries, and fewer special fuel mandates that split the market into small pieces. Congress has a version of that debate in the permitting reform bill I covered earlier.
My Take: Gas Prices Are High Because We Made Supply Hard
I look at a gallon the way I look at any cost sheet. First, find the biggest line items. Then ask what drives them. Here, crude and refining drive the price, and both come down to supply.
Washington can’t control the price of oil. It can, however, control how hard it is to produce, move and refine it here. A country that hasn’t built a major refinery since 1977 shouldn’t be surprised when refining margins nearly double in a tight year.
So my priorities are straightforward. Keep American production growing, because it is the only reason this shock wasn’t worse. Speed up permits for pipelines, refinery expansions and new capacity. And stop piling on fuel rules that make one state’s gasoline illegal to sell in the state next door.
Taxes matter too, but mostly at the state level. A driver in California pays roughly 54 cents more a gallon in state taxes and fees than a driver in Texas. That’s a choice Sacramento makes every day.
The Real Answer Starts With Supply
So why are gas prices so high? This year, it’s a global crude shock on top of a refining system with almost no slack, plus state rules that make some markets far worse than others.
The war-risk premium will fade eventually. The refinery shortage won’t fix itself. If we want cheaper gas the next time the world gets dangerous, we have to build the capacity before the crisis, not argue about it during one.
Sources
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update (weekly U.S., regional and state retail prices, week of Nov. 16, 2026)
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Gasoline Pump Components History (what we pay for in a gallon of regular, through August 2026)
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Short-Term Energy Outlook, November 2026
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Federal and State Motor Fuels Taxes (XLSX, rates as of July 1, 2026)
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Refinery Capacity Report, data as of Jan. 1, 2026
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Gasoline Explained, Why Do Gasoline Prices Fluctuate?
- U.S. Energy Information Administration: Gasoline Explained, Regional Price Differences










