Medicaid expansion is back on the table in four states that have refused it for more than a decade. After the Nov. 3 midterms, Democrats will take the governor’s office in Georgia, Kansas, Texas and Wisconsin. All four campaigned on covering more low-income adults.
Supporters see an opening. I see a contract with blank lines in it. Washington rewrote the terms of the deal last year. Now the new Democratic Congress has promised to rewrite them again. Meanwhile, the federal government borrows heavily to pay its 90% share. My take is simple. No holdout state should sign an open-ended commitment until it knows what the deal will look like in 2028.
What the Midterms Changed in Four Holdout States
Forty states plus Washington, D.C., have adopted the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion, most recently North Carolina in 2023. Ten states have not. The Supreme Court made expansion optional in 2012. Since then, Republican legislatures in the holdout states have mostly said no.
The new map is mixed. In Georgia, Democrats won every statewide office on the ballot and appear poised to control the state House. However, Republicans still hold the state Senate. Texas looks the same: Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa and a Democratic House, facing a Republican Senate. In Kansas, Republicans kept both chambers, though Democrats broke the GOP supermajority in the House. Only in Wisconsin will Democrats control the governor’s office and both chambers, according to Stateline.
Georgia Gov.-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms has called full expansion “a day one priority.” Outgoing Kansas Gov. Laura Kelly once called her Legislature’s refusal “the dumbest thing Kansas has ever done.” The rhetoric is hot. The math is where this gets decided.
Why Supporters Think Medicaid Expansion’s Moment Has Come
The case for expanding deserves a fair hearing, so here it is in its strongest form.
First, the coverage numbers. About 2.6 million uninsured adults in the ten holdout states could become newly eligible, according to a Nov. 13 KFF analysis. Nearly half live in Texas. That count includes about 185,000 Georgians at risk of a coverage gap when the state’s Pathways waiver expires this year.
Supporters also point to the match. Washington pays 90% of the cost for expansion adults. Under regular Medicaid, the federal share ranges from 50% in Wyoming and 59% in Texas to 77% in Mississippi. KFF also cites research linking expansion to better access to care, more financial security and lower mortality. Its polling shows two-thirds of people in holdout states want it.
Rural hospitals are the other big argument. Fewer uninsured patients means less unpaid care. That matters in small towns, where one hospital closure can leave a whole county without an emergency room. I take that seriously. Still, a good outcome for one group doesn’t settle whether the deal is a good one for taxpayers.
What Medicaid Expansion Has Cost Taxpayers So Far
Here is the number most campaign speeches skip. Federal and state governments spent $186.7 billion on the expansion adult group in 2024. That is my total from the CMS-64 New Adult Group Expenditures data, which states report to Washington every quarter. In 2014, the first year, it was $46.6 billion.

Federal Taxpayers Carry Almost All of It
Of that 2024 total, federal taxpayers paid $164.3 billion. States paid $22.4 billion. That works out to an effective federal share of about 88%. Expansion adults also accounted for roughly one in five dollars of all Medicaid medical spending that year.
To be fair, part of the climb reflects new states joining, such as Virginia and North Carolina. The pandemic rule that paused eligibility checks also added to it. Even so, the program is now a permanent line item of nearly $190 billion. At the same time, Washington ran a $409 billion deficit in October alone. The “free” 90% is borrowed money.
What One Million New Enrollees Would Cost
CMS enrollment data show about 21.4 million people in the expansion group in an average month of 2024. Divide spending by enrollment, and the rough cost is about $8,700 per enrollee per year. That’s my arithmetic, not an official estimate, and costs vary a lot by state.
Now apply it. If one million Texans signed up at that national average, the bill would run about $8.7 billion a year. Austin would owe roughly $870 million of it. Federal taxpayers in every other state would cover the rest. I walked through that federal-state split in my piece on how Medicaid is funded. The core problem hasn’t changed. A 90-cent match makes every state dollar look cheap, so spending grows faster than anyone budgets for.
The Deal Washington Rewrote Last Year
Anyone selling expansion as the same offer North Carolina took in 2023 is not reading the current law. The 2025 reconciliation law, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, changed the terms in three ways that matter.
The Signing Bonus Is Gone
Under a 2021 law, new expansion states got a 5-point bump in their regular federal match for two years. Missouri, North Carolina, Oklahoma and South Dakota used it. The 2025 law ended that incentive, so a state that expands now gets the 90% match and nothing extra.
Expansion States Face Tighter Financing Rules
The law limits provider taxes and state directed payments, and the limits are stricter for expansion states. Those are tools states use to raise their share and pay hospitals more. KFF notes that expanding could restrict Wisconsin’s hospital and ambulance taxes and Texas’s hospital tax. In fact, the Wisconsin Hospital Association estimates full expansion could put hundreds of millions of federal dollars at risk, KFF Health News reported.
Work Requirements Arrive, Then Pause
Starting Jan. 1, 2027, expansion adults ages 19 to 64 must show 80 hours a month of work, school, job training or community service. Some qualify for an exclusion. On Nov. 13, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services offered states an optional “hold harmless” period through June 30, 2027. States that opt in must still check compliance. However, they can’t remove anyone solely for failing the rule. States have until Dec. 11 to decide.

My Numbers-First Case Against Rushing
I’m not arguing that low-income working adults don’t matter. Plenty of them are the people who keep small towns running. My argument is narrower. A state should never sign a long-term spending deal when the other party has announced plans to change the terms.
That is exactly where we are. Democrats in Congress say reversing the 2025 Medicaid changes, including work requirements, is a top priority. So far, they haven’t said how. KFF’s Larry Levitt told Stateline a reversal “may make it even more attractive for places like Texas and Georgia to try to expand.” That cuts both ways. A state legislator can’t vote for a program whose rules depend on the next budget fight in Washington.
Brian Blase of the Paragon Health Institute put it plainly to KFF Health News. “When states operate in an environment where they’re uncertain about federal policy, that makes it harder for states to legislate.” He is right.
Write the Exit Door Into the Law
If a holdout state does move forward, it should borrow an idea from a dozen expansion states, including Iowa, my home state. KFF counts nine states, among them Arizona, Arkansas and North Carolina, with trigger laws. Those laws end expansion if the federal match drops, in most cases below 90%. Iowa, Idaho and New Mexico instead require the state to act to limit the cost. A trigger keeps a promise from Washington from turning into a permanent bill for state taxpayers.
Keep Work at the Center
The work requirement is the piece many conservatives wanted all along. In Mississippi, for example, a 2024 expansion bill died because it couldn’t include one. Therefore, any holdout state that expands should write work rules into its own law. That way, a future Congress can’t quietly erase them.
Look at Private Coverage First
More than 4 million Texans picked Affordable Care Act marketplace plans for 2026. Moving people from private coverage into a government program is not automatically a win, especially as 2027 marketplace premiums climb. Wisconsin already covers adults up to the poverty line through a waiver. Even so, Gov.-elect David Crowley has backed away from full expansion since winning. That tells you how hard the trade-offs are.
The Dates That Decide This
Watch Dec. 11, when states tell CMS whether they’ll use the work requirement delay. Then watch January, when the new governors and legislatures are sworn in and Georgia’s Pathways waiver runs out. The real tell will come in the Georgia and Texas state senates, where Republicans still hold the votes. Finally, watch what the new Congress does to the 2025 law.
Until those answers come in, the responsible vote in any holdout capitol is to wait. A program that costs nearly $190 billion a year deserves a contract with fixed terms. Right now, nobody can tell you what those terms will be.
Sources
- KFF: What the Recent Elections and an Evolving Federal Policy Landscape Could Mean for Medicaid Expansion Efforts in 2027 (Nov. 13, 2026)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Medicaid CMS-64 New Adult Group Expenditures (data.medicaid.gov)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: CMS Announces a Hold Harmless Period to Strengthen Medicaid Work Requirement Systems (Nov. 13, 2026)
- KFF Health News: These Governors-Elect Campaigned on Expanding Medicaid. It Won’t Be Easy. (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Stateline: Democratic Wins Put Medicaid Expansion Back in Play in Holdout States (Nov. 6, 2026)
- KFF: Medicaid Expansion Is a Red and Blue State Issue (trigger laws)










