The Justice Department says it found more than 400 Washington noncitizen voters, and it wants their ballots set aside before Election Day on Nov. 3. Acting U.S. Attorney Charles Neil Floyd made the demand Monday in a letter to Secretary of State Steve Hobbs and at a Seattle news conference, The Seattle Times reports. The Washington State Standard , citing that letter, put the figure at 405 people and said prosecutors claim those people, many of them lawful permanent residents, had cast upward of 1,500 ballots in past elections. That is a serious claim. So the right response is not to wave it away or to hype it. Instead, check every name.
What the DOJ Says About Washington Noncitizen Voters
Floyd said the list “is not the full number of noncitizens who have been voting in Washington. This is only the tip of the iceberg,” the Seattle Times reported, and that the federal review so far was based on only a small sample. The Times also reported, via the Associated Press, that the department expects to send a second list before Election Day, and that it acknowledged some people on the list may have since become naturalized U.S. citizens.
So far, no one faces charges. Still, Floyd said he anticipated that would change, the Standard reports. Many of the people flagged are lawful permanent residents, according to his letter. Permanent residents are not citizens. They also are not automatically guilty of illegal voting because their names appeared on a federal list. Each record has to be checked, including whether the person later naturalized, whether the registration is even active, and whether a ballot was actually cast.
Hobbs Pushes Back Hard
Hobbs’s office said it is carefully reviewing the letter. However, it will only respond to requests that follow due process. Hobbs also said the timing, one week out, is “no doubt intended to cast unfounded suspicion on the results.” He questions the data, too. His office says one record on the list dates to 1994, and that since that year 113.5 million primary and general election ballots have been cast in the state, the Times reported. In addition, Hobbs told FOX 13 Seattle that from 1982 to 2025 the state has had only 15 cases of noncitizen voting. The Standard reported that federal authorities have filed more than 60 subpoenas for individual voter records.
Context cuts both ways. The Times noted that the list is a tiny fraction of Washington’s 5 million-plus registered voters. Even so, every illegal ballot cancels out a legal one. A small share is not the same thing as a share that should be ignored. On the other hand, a list that includes a 1994 record, possible new citizens, and, the Standard later emphasized, people the state says may not be registered at all, cannot be treated as 405 proven illegal votes. The work is to separate those categories, in public, with evidence.

Why Washington Noncitizen Voters Deserve a Real Check
Here is where conservatives should be clear. Election integrity is not a conspiracy theory. In fact, it is the foundation of consent. Because Washington votes by mail, ballots get filled out at kitchen tables, far from any poll worker. That system runs on trust, and trust requires verification. If the state can show that the federal names are wrong, it should do that quickly. If some names are right, voters deserve to know, and anyone who voted illegally should face the law.
That is why a stonewall is a problem. Floyd says the review is incomplete and that the first list is only a sample. Granted, courts have limited some of the federal demands for data. But winning a records fight is not the same as answering the eligibility question. If these 405 names are wrong, Olympia can show it. If some are right, hiding behind process will not make the problem smaller. Fiscal conservatives understand audits. You don’t refuse an audit because you think the books are clean. You open the books, show your work, and let the numbers speak.
The DOJ Owes the Public Evidence Too
Accountability runs both ways, though. A press conference is not proof. The DOJ itself admits some names may belong to new citizens. So any case against Washington noncitizen voters belongs in a courtroom with real evidence, not in a news conference days before an election. California offers a warning. As we reported, a Ninth Circuit panel rejected a much larger, last-minute California demand over a flawed list. Sloppy lists hand critics an easy win, even when the underlying concern is legitimate.
The better fix comes earlier: proof of citizenship at registration. As we wrote after Alberta voted to require proof of citizenship, checking before someone registers beats chasing ballots after they arrive. It also protects legal immigrants who follow the rules. A week-before-Election-Day letter, however strongly worded, is a substitute for that earlier check, not the check itself.
What Comes Next
Election Day is Nov. 3. Meanwhile, the DOJ has talked about a second list, and Hobbs is still reviewing the first. The best outcome is simple. First, the DOJ shows its evidence. Next, the state checks each name with due process. Finally, anyone who voted illegally faces the law. Conservatives should keep pressing for that audit. They should also reject the temptation to treat “405” as a completed investigation. It is the start of one.
A mail-ballot state has a special obligation to get this right, and so does a Justice Department that chooses to intervene in the final week. Washington’s system depends on signed envelopes, timely postmarks, and a chain of custody after the drop box. Adding a federal list to that process can be legitimate if the list is accurate and the remedy is individualized. It becomes a mess if counties are asked to freeze ballots based on names that may be outdated, naturalized, inactive, or never registered in the first place. That is why method matters as much as the headline number.
None of that is an argument for looking away. Noncitizen voting is illegal in federal elections, and 15 documented state cases over several decades do not prove that a new list is empty. They do show that Washington has prosecuted some cases before, and that the phenomenon, at least in the state’s own count, has been rare. The honest conservative position is to take rarity and risk seriously at the same time: rare problems still deserve enforcement, and rare problems do not justify treating every flagged envelope as a proven crime. Check every name. Then publish the result.
Update (November 2026)
Added November 2026. On Thursday, November 5, U.S. District Judge Jamal Whitehead issued a temporary restraining order that, for 14 days, bars the Justice Department from demanding that Washington election officials set aside a registered voter’s ballot merely because the name appears on the federal list, and from threatening officials with prosecution for counting votes as state law requires, the Seattle Times reported. The order is not a final ruling on the merits. A hearing on a longer injunction was set for Nov. 18. Counties face a Nov. 24 certification deadline, with the secretary of state to certify by Dec. 3. DOJ said it was reviewing the order. Hobbs called the original letter a “dumpster fire disguised as a legal document” and said eligible voters should not be disenfranchised because of unsupported allegations. The Times noted the list had been described as at least 405 names. Separately, the Supreme Court denied DOJ’s emergency request in the larger California ballot fight. The Washington names still deserve to be checked. They do not, on this record, justify last-minute disruption of lawful ballots.
- California Noncitizen Ballots: DOJ Loses a Race It Started Late (2026-10-27)
- DOJ Takes California’s Voter Rolls to a Grand Jury. Now Bring Proof. (2026-10-29)
- Two Courts Block DOJ Ballot Segregation. The Supreme Court Should Settle It. (2026-10-31)
- DOJ Takes 20,000 California Ballots to the Supreme Court. Rule Fast. (2026-11-02)
- The Supreme Court Says No on 20,000 California Ballots. Now Fix the Rolls. (2026-11-03)
Sources
- The Seattle Times: DOJ demand to set aside ballots of 400-plus alleged noncitizens; Floyd “tip of the iceberg” and 1,500 prior votes; 5 million-plus registered voters; 1994 record
- Washington State Standard: letter figure of 405, lawful permanent residents, 1,500 prior ballots, 60-plus subpoenas
- FOX 13 Seattle: Hobbs says 15 noncitizen-voting cases from 1982 to 2025
- The Seattle Times: Judge Whitehead’s Nov. 5 temporary restraining order
- PBS NewsHour / AP (cited in the original post; this draft could not retrieve the page)










