
Editor’s note, November 14, 2026: I have folded our earlier California ballot posts into this living column and updated the timeline through the Justice Department’s November 6 dismissal. Later developments will be added here instead of as a new URL.
The Supreme Court fight over California’s mail ballots is over, at least for this election. On Monday evening, November 2, the justices turned down the Trump administration’s emergency request to make California set aside about 20,000 mail ballots from voters the federal government flagged as likely noncitizens, NBC News reported. The midterms were the next day.
I think the goal behind the case was right. Only citizens should vote in American elections. I also think the case came too late, and it leaned on a list the courts did not trust. Those two facts can be true at the same time, and conservatives should be willing to say both out loud.
What the Supreme Court Order Says
The order is one sentence long. “The application for injunction pending appeal presented to Justice Kagan and by her referred to the Court is denied,” it reads, according to the BBC. Justice Elena Kagan handles emergency appeals from the 9th Circuit, and she sent this one to the full court. The practical effect is that the lower-court rulings stand.
The court moved fast. According to SCOTUSblog, the order came out shortly before 6 p.m. Eastern, only hours after the morning filing. There were no noted dissents and no explanation. NBC News reported that the court did not even ask California for its views first, as it normally does with the opposing party.
Election law expert Travis Crum of Washington University in St. Louis told NBC News the speed was a signal. “The court acted quickly to show its displeasure for the underlying claims,” he said, comparing it to how the justices turned away Republican requests over a new congressional map this summer. It also reinforced a long-standing principle: federal courts should not step into elections once voting is underway.
How This Fight Got Here
The timeline is why the courts kept saying no, and it is worth walking through in one place.
In July, the Department of Homeland Security told California that as many as 190,000 noncitizens might be on its rolls, Courthouse News reported. The United States sent a letter to California’s secretary of state on July 16 citing a “preliminary” analysis. State officials responded with skepticism and asked how the list was built.
Then, on October 1, California mailed ballots to every registered voter, as state law requires. Los Angeles County began counting on October 5. The Justice Department did not send its list of more than 20,000 names until October 13. It asked defendants to review the list within 48 hours and to set aside ballots from people on it if citizenship could not be confirmed. They refused, and the government sued on October 15.
After that, the department twice asked the trial court for a ruling by November 3. U.S. District Judge David O. Carter, a Clinton appointee, set a hearing for October 27. Then the DOJ changed course. At 8:57 p.m. on October 21, it asked for a ruling by noon the next day. It said it had just learned the county had processed more than 331,000 ballots. About 15 hours later, with no ruling, it appealed, calling the silence a “constructive denial.”
A 2-1 panel of the 9th Circuit dismissed that first emergency appeal for lack of jurisdiction on October 26. “The United States’s claimed emergency, at least in part, is a self-constructed one,” the order said. It added that the government “had the information it needed to seek relief with exigency well before October 21, 2026.”
This was not a ruling from the left alone. Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, joined the majority. In a concurrence, he wrote that even if the court had jurisdiction, he would deny the request on the merits. “There is no dispute that it is unlawful under both federal and California law for noncitizens to vote,” he wrote. In his view, the fight is about procedure, and California may still “craft its own procedures governing congressional elections and ballot challenges in those elections.”
Judge Gabriel Sanchez, a Biden appointee, went further. He said the government asked a federal court “to dictate to a state legislature a matter squarely within the state’s traditional domain.” He also leaned on the Purcell principle: courts should not order last-minute changes to election rules, because those changes can confuse voters and undermine confidence.
The Dissent Was Worth Hearing
Judge Patrick Bumatay, also a Trump appointee, dissented, and I think conservatives should hear him out. “Citizens can vote. Non-citizens can’t. That’s always been true,” he wrote. “An injunction here isn’t changing the rules but applying them.”
His core worry is practical. Once a mail ballot is processed, it can be commingled with lawful ballots. An illegal vote, once counted, can stay counted. He called setting those ballots aside “the bare minimum.” That is a serious argument about the remedy. It does not erase the fact that this appeal came too late, and in the wrong posture.
Why Three Courts in a Row Said No
On October 28, Judge Carter refused to order the ballots set aside. “Never before in American history has the federal government, on the eve of an election, sought to coerce a state and local government to abandon their own constitutional elections procedures and bend to the will of the executive branch,” he wrote, the BBC reported. More than 3.7 million Californians had already voted. He also found that segregating ballots now would work like a voter purge, which federal law bars within 90 days of an election. More than 500,000 ballots had already been processed, meaning envelopes were verified and ballots removed. That would make it nearly impossible to match a ballot to a voter.
On Friday, October 30, a 9th Circuit panel voted 2-1 to deny a second emergency request, the Associated Press reported. Bennett and Sanchez formed the majority again. They wrote that “there is no feasible way to identify and segregate the ballots of specific individuals without potentially catastrophic effects on the entire system.” Bumatay dissented again. “California decided long ago that aliens can’t vote in its elections,” he wrote. “Today, the federal government merely seeks to safeguard that decision. We should have let them try.”
Solicitor General D. John Sauer then took the fight to the Supreme Court in a 19-page filing on November 2. “Once California commingles the challenged ballots with lawful ones, there is no way to get the challenged ballots back,” he wrote. He also argued that “it follows that any ballot cast by an alien is unlawful,” and that California would suffer no “undue hardship.” “That doomsday prediction ignores that segregating ballots is a routine remedy when the lawfulness of ballots is questioned,” he wrote. He is right that courts have used segregation before. He is not entitled to skip past the problems in the list itself.
California has some 23 million registered voters, and more than six million mail ballots had already arrived by Sunday night, November 1, according to the secretary of state’s office.
The List Could Not Carry the Case
The government said it built the list of more than 20,000 names from publicly accessible information and its own review. Its application said those people “are likely not U.S. citizens,” based on “the Executive Branch’s review.” Likely is not the same as proven, and that gap is where the case kept losing.
In a footnote, Bennett pointed to a defense sample of 200 records from the October list. “Among the records for which birthplace information was meaningfully reported, 38.9% indicated that they were born in the United States,” the October 26 order said. Data scientists at UCLA’s Voting Rights Project later reviewed the list under a court order, NPR reported. They found that 42% of the names are not on California’s current voter roll. The analysis also found naturalized citizens on the list. County officials found that many people on the list had no active registration and never got a ballot. The real number of disputed ballots was likely far smaller than 20,000.
Federal lists have stumbled before. When the federal government said it had confirmed 185 noncitizens registered to vote in Nevada, the state responded that all of them were citizens. NBC News noted that a similar federal claim in Nevada had shrunk from 15,903 suspected noncitizen voters to those 185. A list is only as good as the data behind it.
California officials also argued, Roll Call reported, that there was no evidence these people had actually returned ballots or were not citizens. The state had refused to accept a flash drive of names from the administration before the suit was filed. The government did not say, in the October 26 round, how many people on the list had actually returned a ballot.
Prosecute Illegal Votes. Don’t Threaten Election Workers.
I want illegal votes prosecuted. That is not in dispute. On October 19, Justice Department officials said the 20,000 people included 28 who had been criminally charged with illegally voting. Later, on November 2, Los Angeles U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli announced charges against six more people, bringing the total charged in the effort to 34 out of the 20,000 names flagged. Carter himself pointed to those cases as proof the government has a remedy. “If it’s this big, you’ve got a remedy for goodness sakes,” he told Essayli. “Go out and indict.”
That is the right path. What was not the right path was the pressure campaign that ran alongside the civil case. The administration warned California election officials they could face prosecution if they let noncitizens vote, and a federal judge told the Justice Department to stop making such threats. The BBC reported that armed Homeland Security officials had delivered letters to county election workers. Last week of October, prosecutors also began sending grand jury subpoenas to state and local officials, Bloomberg Law reported. Some went to three employees of Los Angeles County’s Registrar-Recorder’s Office for testimony on November 4. A DOJ spokeswoman said that “all agree that noncitizen voting is properly addressed through criminal law,” and that “receiving a subpoena doesn’t mean you are a target.”
Even so, the timing looks like pressure. Loyola Law School’s Justin Levitt noted that the statute of limitations on federal voting offenses is five years. If this is a real criminal investigation, there is no reason it has to happen during the count. I made the same point about the Justice Department’s list of about 400 flagged voters in Washington: charge specific people, one by one, with proof.
On October 30, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson, a Biden appointee in San Francisco, issued a temporary restraining order that barred DOJ and the Department of Homeland Security from demanding ballot segregation by election officials in any state, CNN reported. She found the government likely violated the Voting Rights Act’s ban on attempts to “intimidate, threaten or coerce” people who help others vote. The order expired November 16, with a hearing set for November 13. I have a problem with that order too. It covered officials in every state, and she issued it without DOJ weighing in. In 2025, the Supreme Court curbed universal injunctions over that kind of reach. Federal pressure deserves scrutiny, and so does one courtroom setting terms for 50 states.
The Real Fix Is Before the Ballot Goes Out
Here is the lesson I take from this. The problem is not that judges care about due process. The problem is that checking citizenship after a ballot is mailed is far too late.
The better answer is to verify citizenship when people register, keep voter rolls clean all year, and require states to share data with federal agencies. That approach protects every legal voter. It also costs far less than emergency lawsuits filed in the final days before an election. I said the same thing when a federal judge tossed the Justice Department’s last-minute Alaska Senate suit: election integrity belongs in audits and statutes, not in a courtroom two days before the vote.
There is a limit on how to get there, though. Roll Call notes that an executive order seeking proof of citizenship nationwide was largely stopped by the courts. Under the Constitution, states and Congress set the rules for federal elections. Durable reform has to come through legislation, not orders or lawsuits. That is also why I was glad to see voter ID measures pass in several states on the same November ballot. Concrete rules beat last-minute litigation.
What Happened After the Order
On November 6, the Justice Department filed a notice of voluntary dismissal of the California case. Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office said DOJ dropped it rather than face an evidentiary hearing before Judge Carter set for November 13 on the reliability of its list, according to a state press release. I disagree with Bonta on plenty. On this record, the courts reached the result the law required, and the department chose not to test its list in an open hearing.
Nationally, Democrats won control of both the House and Senate in the November 3 elections. I wrote about what the midterm results do and do not prove in a separate column. This California case is not a reason to doubt the count. It is a reason to do the roll-maintenance work earlier, and in the open, before the next Election Day.
Noncitizen voting is still illegal, and the push for secure elections should go on. Now that energy belongs in Congress and the statehouses, where lasting reforms get written. Clean the list first. Then clean the rolls. Then go to court, if you still have to, with time to spare and evidence that can stand up.
Sources
- NBC News: Supreme Court quickly rejects Trump effort to target alleged noncitizen voters in California
- SCOTUSblog: Supreme Court declines the administration’s request to intervene in the California ballot dispute
- BBC News: Supreme Court rejects the request to stop California counting disputed votes
- Roll Call: Supreme Court denies the DOJ request in the California ballot case
- Associated Press: Supreme Court rejects the administration’s request on California ballots
- Associated Press: 9th Circuit denies the emergency request on California noncitizen ballots
- NPR: contemporaneous account of the Supreme Court filing, the 9th Circuit split, and the 42% list finding
- DOJ emergency application to the Supreme Court (via Just Security)
- U.S. District Court order, dkt. 461 (via California Attorney General)
- U.S. v. California: notice of voluntary dismissal, Nov. 6, 2026
- California Attorney General: press release on the voluntary dismissal
- California Secretary of State: statement on DOJ actions
- CNN: Judge Thompson’s nationwide emergency order on ballot segregation demands
- CBS News: Judge Thompson’s order and Voting Rights Act findings
- Ninth Circuit order, United States v. California, No. 26-7070 (Oct. 26, 2026), as reported by Courthouse News and NBC News










