Join the World of Payne for bold, faith-driven insights and conservative commentary. Stay informed, ignite your passion, and mobilize for change.

,

James Comey Charged a Third Time. This Leak Case Has a High Bar.

The Trump DOJ has charged former FBI Director James Comey a third time, over a 2016 leak to The New York Times that his lawyers say two U.S. Attorneys declined to prosecute. Leaks are serious, but a decade-old case filed without a grand jury has a high bar to clear.

James Comey charged: the steps and columns of a federal courthouse in Washington at dusk under a navy sky, with an American flag

The Trump Justice Department has now gone after James Comey three times. On Monday, October 26, a federal judge in Washington unsealed a case with former FBI Director James Comey charged with leaking national defense information. So the real question is no longer whether the DOJ wants him. Instead, it is whether this case can survive a courtroom.

Judge Trevor McFadden opened the case at Comey’s request. The government did not object, according to the unsealing order. Just hours earlier, a different judge ruled that the DOJ illegally fired his daughter, Maurene Comey, a ruling we covered separately.

James Comey Charged: What the DOJ Alleges

The case centers on an October 5, 2016, New York Times story by reporter Charlie Savage. It reported that Yahoo had aided U.S. email surveillance by adapting a spam filter. At the time, Comey ran the FBI.

Under Count I, Comey allegedly sent a sensitive national defense document to someone not entitled to receive it. That count falls under 18 U.S.C. 793(d), the order states. Count II then charges a conspiracy with “others known and unknown” under 18 U.S.C. 793(d) and (g). The information was filed on October 5, 2026, exactly ten years after the alleged leak.

Prosecutors say Comey wanted to correct a Reuters report from the day before. In a filing, Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Dustin Farahnak wrote that Comey “directed staff to speak to Mr. Savage about specific accuracy concerns related to the Reuters article, and thereby illegally transferred classified information,” NBC News reports. Those are allegations. They have not been proven in court.

Comey Calls It an “Appalling Abuse”

With James Comey charged a third time, his answer came fast in a video on Substack. “It would almost be funny if it weren’t such an appalling abuse of the Department of Justice, one that we cannot become numb to,” he said. He added, “I’m still innocent.”

His lawyers also point to history. They told the court the alleged leak “was investigated by two separate U.S. Attorneys over the past ten years. Both declined to prosecute,” CNBC reports. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald said Comey “will fight these charges vigorously and in the open.” Fitzgerald has also said those earlier reviews took place “during the first Trump administration,” according to coverage of the filings.

This is also the third case. First, a judge tossed a 2025 Virginia indictment after finding that Lindsey Halligan, the prosecutor behind it, held her post invalidly. Then, in April, North Carolina prosecutors indicted Comey over a photo of seashells reading “8647.” He denies wrongdoing there too.

A sealed manila folder with a red classified stripe and a wooden judge's gavel on a dark desk, illustrating the national defense information case

An Information, Not an Indictment

Here is the part that matters most. Federal felony cases normally go through a grand jury. Instead, prosecutors filed this charge on their own on October 5, 2026. Comey’s lawyers argue that the deadline to indict ran out that day, so the case is “time barred.”

The DOJ disagrees. A spokesperson called filing an information to pause the clock “a widely recognized practice in federal court.” Several appeals courts have approved it, the department says. Still, Comey cannot stand trial on the information alone unless he waives indictment. In other words, prosecutors still need a grand jury, if the court allows the clock to be paused this way. That is the weak spot in getting James Comey charged by information alone.

This is not a technicality invented for Comey’s benefit. The statute of limitations exists so the government cannot sit on a file for a decade, then file charges when the politics line up. If an information can quietly stop that clock on the last possible day, judges should say so clearly, with law to back it up. If it cannot, the case should end. Either answer is better than leaving the public to guess.

The same is true of the decision to skip a grand jury at the start. Grand juries are not a courtesy. They are a check on prosecutors, especially in a political case in the nation’s capital. DOJ may yet present this evidence to one. Until it does, and until a judge rules on the deadline, this remains a placeholder charge, not a tested indictment.

The unsealing order also explains why the case was sealed in the first place. The government told the court that unindicted and unnamed co-conspirators appear in the information, and that public notice “would risk compromising ongoing criminal and grand-jury investigations and could endanger cooperating witnesses.” McFadden later unsealed the case anyway, once Comey asked and the government did not object. The rest of the dismissal motion, he wrote, will be addressed “in due course.” Comey has offered to “self-surrender,” according to the order.

With James Comey Charged Again, Equal Justice Is on Trial

Let’s be clear. Leaking classified information is serious. In fact, we recently covered a CIA contractor arrested under the same statute. We said then that the law should apply to everyone. That includes a former FBI director. Comey earned plenty of conservative distrust, and nobody is above the law.

But equal justice cuts both ways. Comey’s lawyers say two sets of prosecutors reviewed this alleged leak and passed. Now, a decade later, the charge arrives without a grand jury. It also comes from an administration whose leader has long treated Comey as a political enemy. Naturally, that invites the charge that this case started with a target, not a crime.

That matters for DOJ credibility. For years, conservatives objected when prosecutors seemed to pick targets first. The standard cannot change just because the target changed. A ten-year-old leak case can still be a real case. It can also be a shortcut around a grand jury and a statute of limitations. The only way to tell the difference is to test the evidence in open court, under the same rules that apply to everyone else.

The other two cases against Comey only raise the stakes. A dismissed indictment built on an invalid appointment already cost the department credibility. A separate seashell-photo case in North Carolina, whatever a jury eventually makes of it, is a different alleged crime from a 2016 classified leak. Stacking cases is not the same thing as proving one of them. If this leak charge is solid, it should be able to stand on its own record: the Times story, the Reuters article, the document prosecutors say was passed, and the decisions of the two U.S. attorneys who already looked at it.

None of that requires sympathy for Comey. It requires consistency. Conservatives have spent years arguing that classified leaks are serious and that famous officials should not get a pass. That argument is stronger, not weaker, when the government is willing to use a grand jury, meet the deadline and try the facts in public. A win that looks like a workaround will not settle the distrust that made this fight matter in the first place.

So if the evidence is strong, take it to a grand jury and let a judge rule on the clock. If the evidence is a recycling of a file that two U.S. attorneys already declined, say so and close it. Either way, James Comey charged is not James Comey convicted. The country can hold a former FBI director to the law without lowering the bar to do it. McFadden now has to decide the clock question. Until he does, the right posture for conservatives is simple: take the allegations seriously, demand a grand jury if the case is real, and make the government prove the charges the right way.

More on This Story

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *