Join the World of Payne for bold, faith-driven insights and conservative commentary. Stay informed, ignite your passion, and mobilize for change.

,

Supreme Court Ends Deportation Limbo. Next Time, Use the Front Door.

The Supreme Court refused to revive administrative closure, the Biden-era rule that let immigration judges shelve deportation cases. Ending deportation limbo is the right result, but the same-day Trump-Texas settlement that killed the rule is a tactic conservatives should think twice about.

Administrative closure ruling: the U.S. Supreme Court building's marble columns and steps at sunset beside an American flag

The Supreme Court just shut a quiet back door in America’s immigration courts. On Tuesday, October 27, the justices refused to revive administrative closure, a Biden-era rule that let immigration judges set deportation cases aside. The order was one sentence long, and no justice publicly dissented.

As a result, the administrative closure rule stays dead, and so does the Trump-Texas deal that killed it. Three cities and an immigrant legal services group had asked the Court to pause that deal. They lost, at least for now, while their appeal continues.

What Administrative Closure Actually Did

Administrative closure lets an immigration judge pull a case off the active docket without deciding it. According to Reuters, via HuffPost, judges used the practice for decades. Over the years, judges applied it in hundreds of thousands of deportation cases. Often, a separate visa petition or an appeal of a criminal conviction was still pending, and the outcome could prevent removal.

The Biden administration formally wrote the practice into a regulation in 2024. That rule replaced a 2020 rule from President Trump’s first term that courts had blocked. Supporters said it helped judges manage crowded dockets and promoted fair treatment. For example, SCOTUSblog notes it let a crime victim or witness seek relief, such as asylum, from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, a separate agency.

Supporters also point to sympathetic cases. Bloomberg Law notes the rule let judges pause proceedings when a person was separately seeking legal protection as a neglected child or a survivor of violent crime.

However, critics saw something else. After all, a closed case is not a decided case. Meanwhile, the person stays in the country, sometimes for years. Texas called the rule “one part of the Biden-Harris Administration’s campaign to undermine our immigration laws.”

Why Administrative Closure Became Amnesty by Delay

The law is fairly plain here. Specifically, Texas pointed out that federal law requires an immigration judge, at the end of a proceeding, to “decide whether an alien is removable from the United States.” Putting a case on a shelf indefinitely does not do that. Instead, it creates a limbo where nobody wins and nobody leaves.

In its lawsuit, Texas argued the rule let immigration judges “effectively grant indefinite amnesty to aliens illegally present in this country.” The state also told the justices that pausing the ruling “would revive a rule the district court declared unlawful, renew the fiscal and sovereign injuries Texas alleged, and unsettle a final judgment accepted by the actual parties.”

That is not mercy. It is a policy choice Congress never made. Immigration judges already have busy dockets, as Reuters noted, and parking cases instead of deciding them does nothing to shrink the pile in a way the public can see. When a case can sit untouched for years, the law on the books stops matching the law in practice, and that gap erodes trust in the whole system.

Conservatives, in fact, have argued this for years. Immigration law should be enforced as written, and changes should come from Congress. We made a similar point when 300,000 visas were revoked: a visa, like a pause button, was never a right.

Stacks of immigration court case files on a shelf, illustrating administrative closure of deportation cases

How the Rule Was Struck Down in One Day

After President Trump returned to office in 2025, the Executive Office for Immigration Review, the Justice Department office that runs the immigration courts, said it would not defend the Biden rule against a legal challenge.

On June 22, Texas sued in Wichita Falls, where Chief U.S. District Judge Reed O’Connor is the only federal judge. Just a few hours later, the Justice Department joined Texas in asking for a final judgment. O’Connor granted it the same day. He struck down the rule nationwide and also barred the agency from adopting a similar rule in the future unless Congress changes the law.

On August 7, Baltimore, New Haven, Columbus and Centro Legal de la Raza moved to join the case so they could defend the rule on appeal, since neither Texas nor the federal government would. O’Connor said they lacked standing. In particular, he rejected the cities’ argument that losing the rule would cost them money because taxpayers in their communities are likely to be deported. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals then refused to put the deal on hold.

On October 9, the coalition took its request to Justice Samuel Alito, who handles emergency matters from the 5th Circuit. After he called for responses, the federal government argued the challengers lacked standing, and Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton argued that administrative closure unlawfully allowed “indefinite non-adjudication,” JURIST reported. Alito referred the request to the full Court, which denied it four days after briefing ended.

The Collusion Charge Deserves an Answer

Still, the way the administrative closure rule died deserves a hard look. The challengers called the deal “egregious collusion.” Their lawyer, Joshua Salzman of Democracy Forward, warned that “any agency can avoid the strictures of” the federal law on agency rulemaking “by advertising its unwillingness to defend a disfavored regulation and by immediately acquiescing to nationwide relief.”

Democracy Forward’s president, Skye Perryman, went further when the group filed. She said the Justice Department “colluded with Texas to erase longstanding immigration procedures in a single day, putting families, survivors of violence, and entire communities at risk.”

On the other hand, Solicitor General D. John Sauer said the challengers wanted to turn a narrow standing fight into “a far-reaching attack on the merits” of the agreement. “This court should not allow applicants to put the cart before the horse,” he wrote.

Here is the uncomfortable truth for conservatives. For years, our side attacked “sue and settle” deals. In those, friendly groups sued Democratic administrations to lock in policies without public comment. Bloomberg Law reports that opponents now use that same word, collusive, for this settlement. It also notes that Wichita Falls has become a favorite forum for conservatives. If it is wrong when the left does it, it is risky when we do it too.

What Comes Next for Administrative Closure

This was an emergency order, not a final ruling. Therefore, the fight continues at the 5th Circuit, where the challengers’ opening brief is due December 1, according to the appeals court docket. In addition, a future administration could try to write a new rule, although O’Connor’s order stands in the way.

The challengers said they were “deeply disappointed” that the Court declined to stop what they called a “backdoor agreement with Texas.” The Justice Department did not respond to Bloomberg’s request for comment.

The durable fix is the same one we pointed to after the Court’s New Hampshire voter ID decision: write it into law. Congress should spell out when immigration judges may pause a case and when they must decide it. That way, no judge, no agency, and no friendly lawsuit can quietly change the rules again.

Bottom line: ending deportation limbo is the right result. Next time, win it through the front door.

Update (November 2026)

Added November 2026. JURIST reported on October 29 that the order leaves more than 300,000 administratively closed cases open to being returned to active dockets. As of early November, the 5th Circuit appeal was still pending, with no ruling on the merits.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *