Join the World of Payne for bold, faith-driven insights and conservative commentary. Stay informed, ignite your passion, and mobilize for change.

October CPI Has No Yearly Rate. The Monthly Math Is Still Hot.

The October CPI rose 0.4%, with core prices up 0.3% for a third straight month, and both beat forecasts. BLS skipped the yearly rate because of last year’s shutdown, but the index levels show prices up 3.9% over 13 months and running near a 5.7% annualized pace over three. The Fed’s December choice is now…

Marble central bank building with tall columns under an overcast sky, illustrating the Fed's rate hike decision after the October CPI report
Bar and line chart of monthly CPI changes from Dec. 2025 to Oct. 2026: headline swung from -0.4% in June to 0.9% in March while core stayed near 0.2% to 0.4%; side panel shows prices up 3.9% headline and 2.9% core over 13 months, and 5.7% and 3.7% annualized over three months
Chart: World of Payne. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; 13-month and annualized figures are World of Payne calculations.
Shopping cart full of groceries beside a long receipt at a checkout counter, with a gas station glowing outside, showing October CPI price pressure

Editor’s note, November 14, 2026: I have turned this into a living column on inflation, jobs-adjacent data, and the Fed in fall 2026. It now folds in the October rate hold, consumer confidence, third-quarter GDP, the manufacturing PMI, construction spending, Treasury’s borrowing estimate, unit labor costs, and consumer credit. Later releases will be added here. Separate columns on the October jobs report, 5% Treasury yields, the producer price index, and existing-home sales remain stand-alone, because each has its own argument.

Washington skipped a number on Tuesday, November 10. The Bureau of Labor Statistics said the October CPI rose 0.4%, after a 0.6% jump in September. Core prices, which leave out food and energy, rose 0.3% for the third straight month. Both beat forecasts by a tenth of a point.

What the report did not include was the headline everyone looks for: the yearly inflation rate. BLS never collected October 2025 prices because of last year’s government shutdown. So there is no official 12-month comparison for most of the index this time.

That gap should not fool anyone. The October CPI data still let you rebuild the trend, and the trend is not good. Inflation is not fading. It is settling in, and the Federal Reserve now has to decide how hard to lean against it in December. I think the committee should treat this as a live problem, not a problem already solved.

What the October CPI Report Actually Said

Start with the pieces. Shelter rose 0.3% and drove more than 30% of the monthly increase. Food jumped 0.5%, its biggest gain since April, after no change in September. Groceries rose 0.4%, with beef up 0.9% and snacks up 1.0%. Restaurant meals rose 0.5%.

Energy cooled from September’s 5.2% surge, but it still climbed 0.7%. Gasoline rose 1.0% after seasonal adjustment. Electricity rose 0.9%. Natural gas service fell 0.8%.

Inside core, the increases were broad. Recreation rose 0.8%. Car insurance rose 0.7%. Hospital services rose 0.8%, and doctors’ services rose 0.4%. Transportation services jumped 0.8%. On the other side, used cars fell 1.2% and communication slipped 0.1%.

Economists surveyed by Dow Jones expected 0.3% headline and 0.2% core, CNBC reported. One tenth sounds small. However, a miss on core matters because core is the part the Fed can actually influence.

Rebuilding the Missing Yearly Rate

There are still honest ways to read the October CPI over time. BLS publishes the raw index levels, so we can compare October with the last month that has a real number.

The unadjusted all-items index hit 337.511 in October. In September 2025, it stood at 324.800. That is a 3.9% rise over 13 months. Core prices, using the seasonally adjusted series, rose about 2.9% over the same stretch.

That 13-month figure is not an official rate, and I should not call it one. Still, it lines up with the forecasts. Before the release, economists expected 3.9% headline inflation over 12 months, up from 3.7% in September.

The short-term math is worse. Over the past three months, headline prices rose 1.4%. At that pace for a full year, inflation would run about 5.7%. Core rose about 0.9% over three months, an annualized pace near 3.7%. Since December, prices are up 4.2% in just ten months.

Bar and line chart of monthly CPI changes from Dec. 2025 to Oct. 2026: headline swung from -0.4% in June to 0.9% in March while core stayed near 0.2% to 0.3% a month.
Chart: World of Payne. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; 13-month and annualized figures are World of Payne calculations.

The chart tells the story better than any single number. Headline inflation swings with gasoline. Core keeps grinding at 0.2% to 0.3% a month. That steady grind, not the spikes, is what worries policymakers.

Energy is still the big headline driver. Among the few items where BLS could publish a 12-month change, gasoline stood out: up 37.4% from a year ago. That is the war in the Middle East at your local pump. Food is the second pressure point. Electricity is a newer worry, up 0.9% in one month, with analysts pointing to the artificial intelligence buildout as one likely factor. Apparel, a category that tends to react to import taxes, rose only 0.1%. New vehicles rose 0.2%. That does not prove tariffs are harmless. But it suggests October’s surprise came mostly from services, food and energy, not from imported goods.

Fall 2026: The Data That Led Here

The October CPI did not arrive in a vacuum. Here is the fall data, in order, that I am now keeping in this column.

In late October, heading into the Fed’s meeting, consumer prices were already up 3.7% over the 12 months ending in September, up from 3.4% in August. Gasoline was up 34.2% in a year and drove more than half of September’s 0.6% monthly increase. The energy index was up 20.4%. Core inflation was 2.6% over the year, up from 2.4% in August. Wages were not keeping up.

On October 28, the Fed kept its key rate at 3.75% to 4% by a 10-2 vote, according to its official statement. The statement said uncertainty remains elevated “owing, in part, to geopolitical developments,” while domestic spending has been resilient, productivity growth is strong, and capital investment is robust. Job gains “have kept pace with the workforce, and the unemployment rate has changed little.” Markets had been pricing in a less than 10% chance of a hike at that meeting. The dissent was the news. Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack both voted to raise rates by a quarter point. Cook’s vote was her first dissent since she joined the Fed in 2022 as a Biden appointee, CNBC reported. Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan and Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari had joined Hammack in dissenting the last time the committee held, in July, then fell in with the majority in October. Average wages had risen just 3% in the 12 months through September, NPR reported, against 3.7% inflation. Mortgage rates had hit a three-year high of 7.4% earlier that month.

The same week, the Conference Board said its consumer confidence index rose 7.5 points to 91.7 in October, up from 84.2 in September. Regular gas averaged $4.27 a gallon, down from $4.48 a month earlier but up from $3.05 a year earlier. The Present Situation Index rose 8.6 points to 120.4. The Expectations Index climbed 6.9 points to 72.6, which only partly reversed three straight monthly declines. Consumers still expected 5.8% inflation over the next year and planned to spend less on big purchases. A bounce in confidence when gas dips a little is not the same thing as inflation coming under control.

On October 29, the Bureau of Economic Analysis said third-quarter GDP grew at a 3.4% annual rate, beating forecasts and topping the 2.2% pace from the spring. Sales to private domestic buyers grew at a 4.9% rate. Consumer spending grew at a 3.8% pace. The strong report card had a catch. The PCE price index, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, rose 3.6% from a year earlier in September. Real disposable income fell 0.3% in September, and the personal saving rate was 3.8%. The economy can grow, and your paycheck can still lose ground.

On November 2, the October manufacturing PMI hit 55.5%, a full point above September and above the 54.5 forecast, according to the ISM report. All five parts of the index grew at the same time. Production climbed to 59%, the highest reading since November 2021. Employment held at 52.4%. The Prices Index dipped to 75.2% from 77.9%, which is still a hot number. Factories are busy, and they are still paying more for inputs.

The same week’s construction spending report showed builders spent 1.9% less in September than in August, a $2.186 trillion annual rate, 2.7% lower than a year earlier. Private residential spending dropped 5.5% in one month, led by a 13% plunge in home improvement spending. Data center construction jumped 8.6% for the month and 90% from a year ago, the Associated General Contractors of America reported. Outside data centers and electric power, private nonresidential categories fell 7.8% over 12 months. I have made a similar point about the housing slump in my column on existing-home sales at a 16-year low: the strength in the economy is uneven, and families buying houses are not the ones catching the boom.

Treasury’s November 2 borrowing estimate looked like a cut and was not. The headline figure for October through December is $618 billion, $10 billion lower than the August forecast. Strip out the higher cash balance Treasury started the quarter with, and the current-quarter borrowing need is $24 billion higher than August projected. January through March 2027 jumps to $800 billion. Heavy federal borrowing is also inflation policy, because it adds demand and forces more Treasury supply into a market that has already pushed the 10-year yield above 5%. I laid out why that yield matters for mortgages and debt service in my Treasury yields column, and why the fiscal path is the problem in my look at the October federal deficit.

On November 6 and 7, two household-level reports landed. Nonfarm business unit labor costs fell 0.7% in the third quarter, because output rose 3.7% while hours barely moved, up 0.1%. Hourly compensation rose 2.9% at an annual rate. Manufacturing was the exception: unit labor costs there rose 2.7% in the quarter and 4.0% year over year. Wages are not the culprit in the headline inflation story. Workers are not pushing up prices. Prices are pushing workers.

The same week, the Fed’s G.19 release said Americans added $27.8 billion in consumer credit in September, far above the $11.5 billion economists expected. Revolving balances grew at a 14.5% annual rate in a single month. Card accounts that charged interest carried an average rate of 22.36% in the third quarter. Total consumer credit outstanding reached $5,224.4 billion. When paychecks trail prices, balances climb, and 22% plastic is a painful way to close the gap.

The Fed’s December Problem

Hours before the October CPI release, Fed Governor Christopher Waller set a bar in a speech in London. If core prices rose 0.3% or more, he said, “a 50 basis point hike in the policy rate should be considered at the December meeting.” He added that “hiking only 25 basis points would put our credibility at risk, a risk I am not eager to take.”

Core came in at exactly 0.3%. Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan then said she sees a need for two more quarter-point increases. She also warned that the PCE price index could move higher when it comes out later this month.

Markets moved fast. Traders fully priced a quarter-point hike at the December 8-9 meeting. The odds of a half-point move jumped from near zero to roughly 14%, according to CME data cited by CNBC. The two-year Treasury yield rose about 20 basis points, its biggest one-day jump since April 2025, Reuters reported. The 10-year yield climbed above 5%. That rate sets the tone for mortgages, car loans and credit cards. Families get hit twice: once at the store, then again when they borrow.

Retirees should do the math as well. The 2027 Social Security raise is 3.6%. I argued in my Social Security column that inflation already spent that COLA, and October’s data back that up. Small businesses are not expecting relief either. A net 37% of firms in the October National Federation of Independent Business survey said they plan to raise prices in the next three months, the highest share since July 2022.

Voters noticed. Even President Trump said on 60 Minutes that voters in the midterms “didn’t like that gasoline was up.” I have a separate read on the producer price index and Secretary Bessent’s argument, and on the October jobs report. Those pieces stay separate because they make distinct arguments. The common thread is the same: the cost of living is the record this government will be judged on.

The Conservative Case: Let the Fed Do Its Job

Here is where I land. First, the Fed must stay independent. Pressure on a central bank to keep rates low is how a 4% inflation problem becomes a 7% one. If the data call for a larger hike, the Fed should make it, whatever the politics. Cook and Hammack had the stronger case in October. Because the economy is strong, now is the time to get prices back under control.

Second, the Fed cannot do this alone. Washington ran a deficit that borrowed about 27 cents of every dollar it spent last fiscal year. Heavy federal borrowing adds demand to an economy that is already running hot. Spending restraint is anti-inflation policy.

Third, supply is the cheapest cure. More American oil, natural gas, and electricity generation would ease the energy prices that keep jolting the headline number. Faster permits for pipelines, power plants, and transmission lines would do more than any price cap.

Finally, avoid the easy fixes that fail. Price controls, gas tax holidays, and new stimulus checks all sound helpful. In practice, they either create shortages or pour more fuel on demand. The 1970s already ran that experiment, and it ended with a painful recession to break inflation.

What I am watching next is the December 8-9 meeting, the next PCE release, and whether the 10-year yield stays above 5%. If you want one sentence to take away from this fall’s data, take this one: the yearly CPI number is missing, and the rest of the evidence is not.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *