
Three Cabinet secretaries are gone in under seven weeks. Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer resigned on Monday, April 20, while under an inspector general investigation. She follows Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, fired on March 5, and Attorney General Pam Bondi, fired on April 2. That much Cabinet turnover this fast would lead every conservative show for a week if it happened under a Democratic president. The same standard has to apply when it is our side.
This is not an argument against the administration. It is an argument for the kind of disciplined, mission-focused government conservatives say we want. Here is what happened in each case, how it compares to past administrations, and what accountability should look like from here.
What Happened at the Labor Department
In January, the New York Post reported that the Labor Department’s inspector general was looking into complaints that Chavez-DeRemer was having an affair with a subordinate, drinking on the job, and using taxpayer-funded travel to visit friends and family, according to NPR. NBC News reported that the subordinate was a member of her security detail, and that he was placed on leave in January. In early March, two of her top aides left their posts after an inquiry into whether official events had been set up as cover for personal travel.
There was more. The New York Times reported in February that her husband, Shawn DeRemer, had been banned from Labor Department headquarters after two women who work there accused him of inappropriate touching. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia said there was “no indication of a crime,” and his lawyers said he “categorically denies every allegation,” NBC News reported.
The timing of her exit matters. According to NBC, the inspector general’s probe was nearly finished, and an interview with Chavez-DeRemer, one of its last steps, had been scheduled for this week. She resigned first. Her attorney, Nick Oberheiden, said the resignation “is not the result of legal wrongdoings. It is a personal decision.” In a post on X, she blamed “high-ranked deep state actors” working with “the one-sided news media.” The White House said she is leaving for the private sector, and Deputy Secretary Keith Sonderling is now acting secretary.
Career-bureaucrat hostility toward Republican administrations is real, and leaks deserve scrutiny. But aides who lost their jobs, a husband barred from the building, and a resignation days before an IG interview are not leaks. They are facts on the public record. The IG’s findings are still to come, and she deserves to be judged on them, not on anonymous sourcing. Her decision to leave before answering questions does not make those questions go away.
Kristi Noem and the $220 Million Ad Campaign
Noem’s exit came after back-to-back hearings in early March. The sharpest questions came from Republicans, not Democrats. At the Senate Judiciary Committee, Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana asked how a $220 million television campaign that featured the secretary herself fit an administration fighting waste. He noted that the contracts were not competitively bid and that one contractor had been formed 11 days before it was picked, The Hill reported. At a House hearing that week, she defended the contracting process, according to Reuters.
Noem testified that the president knew about the campaign. Trump told reporters he did not. “I spent less money than that to become president. I didn’t know about it,” he told NBC News. He announced the change on Truth Social that Thursday and named Sen. Markwayne Mullin of Oklahoma as her replacement, with Noem moving to a new role as special envoy for the Shield of the Americas. The Senate confirmed Mullin 54-45 on March 23, and his first stated priority was getting DHS funded so its employees could be paid, according to the department.
For fiscal conservatives, this one is the easiest call. Spending $220 million in no-bid contracts on ads starring the official who approved them is exactly the kind of spending we would condemn from a Democratic cabinet. Republican senators said so on the record, and they were right to.
Pam Bondi and the Epstein Files
Trump announced on April 2 that Bondi was out and that Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche would serve as acting attorney general. Reuters reported, citing sources, that the president had grown frustrated with her performance, especially the release of the Jeffrey Epstein files. Blanche has disputed that Epstein was the reason.
Either way, the record is not good. Bondi had promised a full accounting of the Epstein files. After Congress passed the Epstein Files Transparency Act, the department missed disclosure deadlines and faced accusations that documents were withheld, The Guardian reported. NBC News reported that about 200,000 files were held back or redacted, and the law’s Republican co-author, Rep. Thomas Massie, has said that may violate the act. House Oversight had also subpoenaed Bondi to testify on April 14. Firing the official does not answer the questions the subpoena was meant to answer.
How This Cabinet Turnover Compares to the First Term
Brookings scholar Kathryn Dunn Tenpas tracks Cabinet turnover across administrations, counting the 15 department heads in the line of succession. By her measure, the first Trump administration had turnover in nine of those 15 posts within 32 months. That beat the full first terms of Reagan, Clinton, George W. Bush and Obama, and George H.W. Bush’s one term, NBC News reported in 2019.
The second term started out very differently. In its first year there was no Cabinet turnover at all, NPR reported in January, compared with two Cabinet changes in 2017. Tenpas and Chris Piper of the Partnership for Public Service credited the administration with a more stable team, while warning that presidents usually see more departures in year two. That is now happening. With Noem, Bondi and Chavez-DeRemer gone, three of the 15 positions have turned over, or 20 percent, on the Brookings tracker, and all three left in about seven weeks.
Why Cabinet Turnover Matters for Conservative Goals
Turnover is not just a headline problem. When a secretary leaves, the department runs on an acting official. Under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act, an acting officer can generally serve 210 days from the vacancy, or longer while a nomination is pending in the Senate. Acting leaders can keep the lights on, but they rarely have the authority or political capital to drive major change.
That hurts our priorities. DHS runs immigration enforcement, the issue at the center of the 2024 campaign. The Justice Department is supposed to restore public trust in equal justice. The Labor Department writes the regulations that small businesses live under, and its Bureau of Labor Statistics produces the jobs numbers markets depend on. All of this is happening while the White House rebuilds its trade policy after the Supreme Court struck down its emergency tariffs in February. Every new confirmation fight uses up Senate floor time that could go to judges, spending cuts or border legislation.
The Accountability Standard Conservatives Should Apply
Conservatives believe in personal responsibility, limited government and careful stewardship of taxpayer money. Those principles do not come with a partisan exemption. A fair standard for any Cabinet official, from either party, looks like this:
- Taxpayer money is not a personal brand budget. Ad campaigns starring the official, no-bid contracts, and official travel built around personal trips should be disqualifying.
- Promises to the public are binding. If you promise transparency, as Bondi did on Epstein, you deliver it or explain specifically why you cannot.
- Answer the investigators. Inspectors general exist to check the executive branch, including ours. Resigning before an interview should not end the inquiry, and the final report should be released.
- “Deep state” is not a defense. Bureaucratic hostility is real, but it does not explain away conduct that is on the record.
- Vet before you nominate. The cheapest fix for turnover is better vetting before the confirmation vote.
Applying that standard is not disloyalty. It is how a movement earns the right to criticize the other side.
What to Watch Next
- Nominees. Whether the president sends Senate-confirmable nominees for Labor and Justice quickly, or leaves acting officials in place.
- The Labor IG report. Whether the inspector general finishes and releases its findings now that the secretary has left.
- The Bondi subpoena. Whether House Oversight still pursues her testimony, or moves the questions to Blanche.
- DHS under Mullin. Whether the department’s funding is restored and the ad contracts get a real audit.
- More departures. Tenpas has noted that departures usually climb in a president’s second year. Three exits in seven weeks may not be the end.
Conservatives should want this administration to succeed. That is exactly why we have to say out loud when it falls short.
Update: What the Inspector General Found
Added November 2026. The Labor Department’s Office of Inspector General released its report of investigation, dated September 3, 2026. The OIG interviewed 53 current and former employees and reviewed more than 500 documents, images and videos. Applying a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard, it found Chavez-DeRemer’s conduct inconsistent with applicable standards in six areas: workplace harassment policy, an inappropriately close relationship with the agent supervising her protective detail, combining personal and official travel, alcohol on federal property, directing staff to do personal tasks, and failing to report gifts. The OIG said the evidence was not sufficient to establish a romantic or sexual relationship. Her attorney declined to make her available for the interview scheduled for April 21, and the report went to the acting secretary for whatever action he deems appropriate.
Sources
- NBC News: Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer resigns amid misconduct probe
- NPR: Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer out amid misconduct investigation
- Department of Labor OIG: Report of Investigation (PDF)
- AP: Trump fires Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem
- Reuters: Trump says he fired Bondi, appoints Blanche as acting attorney general
- Brookings: Tracking turnover in the second Trump administration
- Brookings: Assessing President Trump’s second-term staffing record
- NPR: Less personnel drama but still sky-high turnover one year into Trump’s new term
- NBC News (2019): White House turnover is breaking records
- NBC News: What led Trump to replace Kristi Noem
- Reuters: Noem defends $220 million ad campaign amid lawmaker scrutiny
- The Hill: Trump “never knew” of Noem’s $220M ad campaign
- U.S. Senate: Roll call vote 63, Mullin confirmation
- DHS: Senate confirms Markwayne Mullin as Secretary
- Reuters: Trump fires Pam Bondi as US attorney general
- The Guardian: Bondi out, Blanche in, and the Epstein investigation
- NBC News: Todd Blanche’s rise to attorney general
- Reuters: US Supreme Court strikes down Trump’s global tariffs
- 5 U.S.C. § 3346: Vacancies Act time limits










