Join the World of Payne for bold, faith-driven insights and conservative commentary. Stay informed, ignite your passion, and mobilize for change.

Beef Prices Need More Cattle, Not Another 90-Day Import Fix

Beef prices are still near records, and the 90-day low-tariff import quota for lean beef ends Nov. 30. Importers used about a third of the first two batches, ranchers lost an estimated $140 to $165 per cull cow, and one economist found ground beef only 8 to 10 cents a pound below his forecast. Let…

Beef cattle grazing on a frosty Midwest pasture at sunrise, the herd at the center of high beef prices

Beef prices are still sitting near record highs, and Washington’s 90-day import fix is about to run out. On Aug. 26, President Trump signed a proclamation that let an extra 300,000 metric tons of lean beef trimmings into the country at the low, in-quota tariff rate. The last batch closes Nov. 30.

So did it work? Two and a half months in, the numbers give a fairly clear answer. Ranchers felt it. Shoppers mostly didn’t. My take is that the White House should let this program expire on schedule and put its energy into the one thing that actually brings beef prices down for good: more cattle.

What the 90-Day Import Plan Promised

Start with what the administration said it would do. According to the White House fact sheet, the proclamation opened 100,000 tons a month for three months, starting Sept. 1. It applied only to lean trimmings. Those are the lean cuts processors blend with fattier U.S. beef to make ground beef. The plan also “encourages beef to be sold at a 25% discount from the going import price.”

The White House said the move would “increase beef supply by roughly 10% over current projections.” It also promised the extra beef “will only compete with cull cow markets” and would not significantly hurt the fed cattle market.

That was a fair goal. Ground beef is the cut working families lean on most, and its price has climbed hard. Still, a 90-day window was always a test of whether importers would even bother.

What the Numbers Say About Beef Prices So Far

First, the price history. The Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks the average U.S. price of 100% ground beef. In October 2017, a pound cost $3.69. By October 2024, it was $5.59. This October, it was $6.76, a few cents below August’s record of $6.92.

Line chart of beef prices for 100% ground beef from 2017 to October 2026, rising from $3.69 a pound in October 2017 to a record $6.92 in August 2026 and $6.76 in October 2026, with the September to November 2026 import quota window shaded
Chart: World of Payne. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Average Price Data, Ground Beef, 100% Beef, U.S. City Average (APU0000703112), through October 2026.

In other words, ground beef is up about 83% in nine years and about 21% in the last two alone. That is why this fight matters at the dinner table.

The Quota Never Filled

The first problem is simple. Importers left most of the window unused. Customs data show about 37,500 tons entered under the September batch. The October batch was only 30.5% full when it expired, according to a Customs and Border Protection quota report. Together, that is roughly 68,000 tons out of the first 200,000 offered, or about a third.

Andrew Anderson, an agricultural economist at Utah State University, ran the numbers for the Livestock Marketing Information Center. In his Nov. 12 analysis, he estimated that about 33,000 tons of truly new beef arrived in September. That came in below even his own “low” scenario from August.

Ranchers Paid, Shoppers Barely Noticed

Next, look at who absorbed the hit. Anderson found that domestic 90% lean trimmings ran about 5% below his model’s prediction in September and October. Cull cow prices came in 7.1% and 9.3% below predicted. He puts that at roughly $140 to $165 per head on a 1,200-pound cow.

Meanwhile, retail ground beef ran just 1.2% to 1.4% below his prediction. That is 8 to 10 cents a pound, and it falls inside his model’s error range. In his words, the policy “has not yet produced measurable savings for consumers,” and “the cost has fallen mainly on producers selling cull cows this fall.”

To be fair, he also notes that savings take time to move down the supply chain, so retail prices could still drift lower. But in August, his own estimate called for ground beef to fall 8% to 15%. A dime a pound is not that.

Why Beef Prices Stay High: The Herd Is Too Small

The real shortage is not foreign trimmings. It is American cattle. The USDA’s January cattle report counted 86.2 million cattle and calves on Jan. 1, down from 86.5 million a year earlier. Beef cows fell 1% to 27.6 million. The 2025 calf crop dropped 2% to 32.9 million head. Even the White House describes the herd as the smallest in 75 years.

Last week’s data point the same way. In its Nov. 10 supply and demand report, the USDA cut its beef production forecast for both 2026 and 2027. It now expects 24.83 billion pounds this year, down from 26.07 billion in 2025. That is a drop of nearly 5%. For 2027, it projects 24.59 billion pounds and blames “lower-than-expected placements in the second half of 2026.”

Imports are already filling part of that gap. The USDA now projects 6.44 billion pounds of beef imports this year, up from 5.39 billion in 2025. That is a 19% jump. The special quota beef, roughly 150 million pounds so far, explains only a small slice of it. In short, ordinary trade is already doing most of what the proclamation tried to force.

Then there is the southern border. Ports closed to Mexican cattle in 2025 to keep the New World screwworm out. The White House says that closure cost “hundreds of thousands of metric tons of beef.” That loss alone is far larger than what the quota actually brought in.

Packages of fresh ground beef in a grocery store meat case, where beef prices remain near record highs

The Case for Extending It, Taken Seriously

Supporters of an extension have a point worth hearing. Families are stretched, and ground beef is a staple. The October consumer price index showed beef up 0.9% in a single month, as I noted in my October CPI column. If imports shave even a dime off a pound, that adds up for a family that buys ground beef every week.

They would also argue that wholesale savings just need more time to reach the meat case, and Anderson leaves that door open. I also don’t think imports are the enemy. Lower trade barriers usually help consumers. A tariff is a tax paid by the American importer, as I explained in my piece on how tariffs work.

On the other side, ranchers say the program hit them at the worst possible time. A herd rebuilds over years, not months. A rancher deciding whether to keep a heifer for breeding or sell her needs confidence that prices will hold. Knocking cull cow prices down 7% to 9% sends exactly the wrong message.

That concern crosses party lines. In September, Iowa Republican Zach Nunn and New Mexico Democrat Gabe Vasquez backed the BEEF Act, H.R. 10509. It would suspend the August proclamation, require Congress to approve future import expansions and create a USDA advisory board on rebuilding the herd. The bill has not moved out of committee.

My Take: Let It Expire and Fix the Supply Side

I would let the program end on Nov. 30, as written. My reason is not protectionism. It is that a stop-start policy delivered a small, uncertain benefit for shoppers and a clear cost for the people who grow the herd.

Reopen the Border as Fast as Safety Allows

The quickest real supply boost sits at the southern border. The USDA reopened Columbus, N.M., to Mexican cattle on Oct. 26 and has Nogales, Ariz., scheduled for Nov. 30 if conditions hold. Keeping screwworm out comes first. Even so, every safe port that reopens adds cattle to American feedlots without undercutting American ranchers.

Give Ranchers a Steady Signal

Second, Washington should stop moving the goalposts. This year alone brought a February proclamation on beef imports and then the August one. Ranchers who watch policy swing every few months will hold back on investment. Beef replacement heifers were up 1% in January, an early sign of rebuilding. Policy should protect that trend, not interrupt it.

Keep Normal Trade Open

Finally, none of this means closing the door. Regular imports are already up sharply this year without a special proclamation. Let that trade keep working on stable, predictable terms. Steady rules beat 90-day experiments.

What to Watch Before Christmas

First, watch whether the White House lets Nov. 30 pass quietly or announces another round. Second, watch Nogales, which is set to reopen to cattle the same day. Third, Dec. 10 brings two reports: the November CPI and the next USDA supply estimate. The CPI will cover the final import batch, so it is the cleanest test yet.

Energy costs are a wildcard, too. Diesel was still above $6 a gallon when I wrote about diesel prices last week, and nearly every pound of beef rides a truck.

Here is the bottom line. Ground beef is down a few cents from its August peak, but the herd is still near 75-year lows. You cannot import your way out of that for long. Cheaper beef will come from more calves on American pasture, and Washington’s job is to stop making that harder.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *